ImprovMX vs. Fastmail
ImprovMX offers advanced email forwarding to your existing inbox (Gmail, Outlook, etc.), with the option to send via SMTP. Fastmail is a paid hosted mailbox service: they provide the inbox, so you receive, read, and send mail in Fastmail.
Your choice largely depends on if you need a hosted inbox or prefer to use your existing inbox.
Feature
ImprovMX
Fastmail
Free plan
Free forwarding for one domain. Paid plans for scale.
Paid service only (after 30-day trial)
Mailbox hosting
No mailbox hosting, forwards to existing inbox
Hosted mailbox with contacts and calendar
Apps
Just a web app
Web and mobile apps
Setup
Must setup DNS records for forwarding and sending
Easy inbox creation, but a hassle to migrate
Advanced Forwarding
Rules routing, regexes, multi-destination and wildcards[1]
Mailbox rules and regexes
Logging/Analytics
Offers detailed mail logs and log retention > 7 days
No mail log view — troubleshooting is difficult
Compliance
GDPR compliant
GDPR compliant
[1] We offer rules routing, wildcard addresses, multiple recipient destinations, regex aliases and webhooks.